is it the one in article ´goodwin´?
No, Ana-Lucia finds it on one of the Others that attacks her the second time they come back to the camp. While searching for some form of identification, she finds the knife as well as "the list" of people the Others are supposed to take from the camp. Goodwin asks her for the knife while they are hiking together, to cut a piece of fruit. She asks for it back, to show him the US Army engraving, just before she reveals to Goodwin that she knows he wasn't on the plane, which starts the skirmish that ends in Goodwin's death. (Just watched the episode again today ;-) ) -- «««Joseph»»» 11:43, 28 February 2006 (PST)