Jin: Recruit or Captive?[]
Jin is not bound up. He appears to be staying there of his own free will. I think he's a recruit. Thoughts? cgmv123TalkContribsE-mail 12:34, February 24, 2010 (UTC)
- But Claire's crazy. Not being tied up doesn't means he's staying on his own free will..--Gonzalo84 17:49, February 25, 2010 (UTC)
- I think he's only going along with it out of fear of getting killed by crazy!Claire. He's not a captive, but he's also not there out of his free will. --Golden Monkey 18:03, February 25, 2010 (UTC)
Jacob's cabin and Hydra island[]
Based on Claire's reappearance, there is overwhelming evidence that the Cabin is not Jacob's. Newsflash: Hydra Island is captured by the MiB.16:33, March 10, 2010 (UTC)
- Newsflash Are you joking?? When did MIB capture the hydra island? When he was there he was pretending to be locke with absolutely no power and has been on the main island since. -- B1G CZYGS Talk Contribs 22:23, March 10, 2010 (UTC)
"Christian" and "Jacob"[]
I've got to assume that the yellow "unknown" status is because we don't know if they are/were/ever were part of MiB's faction. Because in no was has this been confirmed. "A long time" (Ilana saying that the cabin hasn't been used by Jacob) could be a year or two, not necessarily three. And while I personally believe that she was intending for it to mean MiB, I can't accept that Christian is on his "team", especially without any real confirmation. We might as well put every one who has ever been an Other on this page since I could come up with a way to half-wittedly prove that Ben was taking orders from MiB in the cabin, or was making up orders.