- As far as I remember this person doesn't exists. The one who took them to see Adam was Doctor (St. Sebastian).--CaptainInsano 10:00, 7 January 2007 (PST)
- Indeed I've looked at the DVD, and it was the doctor advising them about Adam. Furthermore this nurse does not appear anywhere in the ep. I've also looked at the credits and she is not listed amongst the co-stars....So although she may have been originally credited it seems her scene(s) were cut--Kivipat
- Okay, i didn't remember a nurse either, I'll add to the page that she wasn't included so her scenes were obviously cut.--Mr.Leaf 17:35, 9 January 2007 (PST)
- Delete - for my reasons above --Kivipat
- Keep although she may not be in the show she should still be included on this wiki. There are other characters who's scenes were cut here. I'll see if I can find them but this page should stay.Mr.Leaf 12:35, 10 January 2007 (PST)
- I guess you're talking about something like the Little girl character. OK..I'll amend my vote to a qualified keep - the qualification being that article should be re-worded to reflect the character's deuterocanonical status Kivipat
- Deuterocanoned it Kivipat
- Also, look at it like this: someone might go on Medianet, see the pic of the girl, wonder what it's about, come on here, and search for it. There is a purpose for that article existing. This article is different; why would anyone search for it? So, delete. -- Lost Soul talk contribs 12:18, 10 January 2007 (PST)
- However..someone could just as easily see the original credit for this nurse at Medianet (or at another Lost site) and want to find out something about the character (even if it is that they don't exist). I have to stick with Keep Kivipat
- Although the above is true, she is credited as a guest star and therefore there are links to this page. Does it really hurt to keep the page? People are going to see a link to her and wonder why there is no article on her. I would have never known without this page that she didn't appear in the show. This article does have a purpose, to tell people that while she was going to be in the show she never was. Aren't we supposed to have as much info on Lost as we can? Well this is directly related to Lost, and should be kept.--Mr.Leaf 12:35, 10 January 2007 (PST)
I am very sorry for getting the information wrong when I made this page; I did it off memory and my memory is faulty at times. I assumed that if I was wrong, someone would change it, as they did, so thank you for doing that. --LOCI!
- Delete Since she didn't appear on the show, and it's very unlikely someone months later would care about Medianet listings of cast that played unnamed characters (as opposed to the Little Girl article, which raised a lot of interest online). Also, may cause confusion later. The actress' name could be left up, crediting that she was given a cut role. --PandoraX 10:33, 14 January 2007 (PST)
- I'd go with that - We certainly need some kind of precedent as there are likely to be other cut characters 'weeded out' in days to come. I guess both her actor & character entry in the "Abandoned" episode infobox should redirect to her actor page then?.--Kivipat
- Keep - However a rename should be done. I think we should keep it since it did appear in the original press release, though the scene was probably edited out. I suggest renaming to Nurse (Abandoned) and make it clear in the beginning of the article that this character never made it on-screen. -- Jabberwock talk contribs email - 10:26, 23 January 2007 (PST)
- Delete- Just put a line on the actors page that she was cast for a role that was cut. If she didn't even make the deleted scenes, and wasn't credited, they might still use her for something else another time. For now, just delete this, and we can make a new page if that ever happens. -BearDog 17:19, 24 January 2007 (PST)