Jabrwocky7 (talk | contribs) m (→Renaming) |
|||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
* '''Not Yet''' We can't rename it until it's confirmed it's the same character/played by the same actor. So far, the controversy is just that they are similar looking, but Lost is notorious for giving people confusion with that, and as Santa noted, we need a source first. Happy to rename it after that. --{{User:PandoraX/sig}} 20:08, 19 November 2006 (PST) |
* '''Not Yet''' We can't rename it until it's confirmed it's the same character/played by the same actor. So far, the controversy is just that they are similar looking, but Lost is notorious for giving people confusion with that, and as Santa noted, we need a source first. Happy to rename it after that. --{{User:PandoraX/sig}} 20:08, 19 November 2006 (PST) |
||
* Nothing definitive, but lost.wikia credits Joah Buley as Luke, with screenshot goodness. [http://lost.wikia.com/wiki/Luke]. --{{User:Jabberwock/sig}} - 20:01, 20 November 2006 (PST) |
* Nothing definitive, but lost.wikia credits Joah Buley as Luke, with screenshot goodness. [http://lost.wikia.com/wiki/Luke]. --{{User:Jabberwock/sig}} - 20:01, 20 November 2006 (PST) |
||
| + | *Also IMDB credits Joah Buley as Luke, and has a picture of him on location for Lost [http://imdb.com/gallery/hh/1731349/iid_1188552.jpg.html?path=pgallery&path_key=Buley,%20Joah&seq=5]. The screenshot at lost.wikia and his picture at IMDB look very similar. Can we comfirm that Luke is Joah Buley and that that screenshot of him with Juliet is indeed him?--[[User:Mr.Leaf|Mr.Leaf]] 13:27, 9 December 2006 (PST) |
||
=Theories Section= |
=Theories Section= |
||
Revision as of 21:27, 9 December 2006
Who is he?
Who is Luke? I don't remember that someone mentioned his name in the episode... ODK Talk Sandbox 17:15, 12 October 2006 (PDT)
Picture is of Matthew
Um, isn't the guy in the picture Matthew? I remember reading in a blog that a father and son would be playing others, one of them would be Matthew and his pic was of this guy..--Sauron18 13:13, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Please give a URL for that source. For now, this Other seems to match the headshot of the actor. This is not necessarily a contradiction as pre-broadcast names of characters have been known to change (e.g. Eko was formerly Emeka in news reports from official sources); Matthew may be the same as Luke. -- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯ Talk 13:17, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- It was posted Here [1] (Scroll down). The actor who plays Matthew is Dustin Geiger, and that is definetley the same person who some claim is Luke. --Sauron18 13:39, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Actually, I'm 100% Sure that the Other in question is Matthew, played by Dustin Geiger. Here [2] is a comparison picture if you want to see. As an aside, his father is the "big guy" that Sawyer talks about (the one who hits him) --Sauron18 13:48, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Headshot photos are notoriously different from how people look in Lost. I don't think the photo of Dustin Geiger looks like this character; the jaw size and eyes seem very different. However, you have claimed you are 100% sure. If so, please note your source, e.g. are you Dustin, or have you spoken with him personally, or seen an article that mentions his appearance with a screecap, etc.? Thanks. For now I've reverted, with a note that you can remove the photo outside of theories. If you provide your source, then we can go with your content, otherwise let's retain the theories please. -- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯ Talk 14:52, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Since it is not 100% sure, then fine, theory picture is okay, but it is 98% certain, and it will be 100% in two weeks. But until then, sure. --Sauron18 14:54, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Headshot photos are notoriously different from how people look in Lost. I don't think the photo of Dustin Geiger looks like this character; the jaw size and eyes seem very different. However, you have claimed you are 100% sure. If so, please note your source, e.g. are you Dustin, or have you spoken with him personally, or seen an article that mentions his appearance with a screecap, etc.? Thanks. For now I've reverted, with a note that you can remove the photo outside of theories. If you provide your source, then we can go with your content, otherwise let's retain the theories please. -- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯ Talk 14:52, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- Actually, I'm 100% Sure that the Other in question is Matthew, played by Dustin Geiger. Here [2] is a comparison picture if you want to see. As an aside, his father is the "big guy" that Sawyer talks about (the one who hits him) --Sauron18 13:48, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
- It was posted Here [1] (Scroll down). The actor who plays Matthew is Dustin Geiger, and that is definetley the same person who some claim is Luke. --Sauron18 13:39, 13 October 2006 (PDT)
Renaming
- This artile should be renamed to Matthew. If you can figure out how to get that into the main article; I tried and I'm not familair with URL type. THe discussion above (which is still not resolved) seems to indicate that Matthew=Luke -- David 15 November 2006 20:30 PDT
- Not Yet We can't rename it until it's confirmed it's the same character/played by the same actor. So far, the controversy is just that they are similar looking, but Lost is notorious for giving people confusion with that, and as Santa noted, we need a source first. Happy to rename it after that. --PandoraX 20:08, 19 November 2006 (PST)
- Nothing definitive, but lost.wikia credits Joah Buley as Luke, with screenshot goodness. [3]. -- Jabberwock talk contribs email - 20:01, 20 November 2006 (PST)
- Also IMDB credits Joah Buley as Luke, and has a picture of him on location for Lost [4]. The screenshot at lost.wikia and his picture at IMDB look very similar. Can we comfirm that Luke is Joah Buley and that that screenshot of him with Juliet is indeed him?--Mr.Leaf 13:27, 9 December 2006 (PST)
Theories Section
- Should the theories be moved to the theories page? They seem to directly correalte and aren't really theories. --David 15 November 2006 20:30 PDT