Lostpedia
mNo edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 5: Line 5:
 
*OK will separate the transcript from the article. Regarding the other issue, the easiest solution to me seem to be to interleave both transcripts: Standard dialog AND enhanced, but keep formatting somehow distinct, whether it be Tabs, Boldface, Size, Italics, <nowiki>using <pre>...</pre>, etc., or even a small quote box for each caption. I don't think we should "footnote" the standard transcript in a way that requires the reader to go back and forth between two blocks of text. --~~~~
 
*OK will separate the transcript from the article. Regarding the other issue, the easiest solution to me seem to be to interleave both transcripts: Standard dialog AND enhanced, but keep formatting somehow distinct, whether it be Tabs, Boldface, Size, Italics, <nowiki>using <pre>...</pre>, etc., or even a small quote box for each caption. I don't think we should "footnote" the standard transcript in a way that requires the reader to go back and forth between two blocks of text. --~~~~
   
==Merge==
+
== Merge ==
   
 
I think this article should be merged into the episode's main article as it doesn't need an entire page on its own. The info within it can be moved to a section of the [[Through the Looking Glass]] page, and a link to the transcript added. An enhanced version of an episode with pop-up factoids such as this does not require an entire new page, as the episode itself is in no way different, and should therefore be merged. --~~~
 
I think this article should be merged into the episode's main article as it doesn't need an entire page on its own. The info within it can be moved to a section of the [[Through the Looking Glass]] page, and a link to the transcript added. An enhanced version of an episode with pop-up factoids such as this does not require an entire new page, as the episode itself is in no way different, and should therefore be merged. --~~~

Revision as of 11:31, 4 February 2008

Discussion

  • Wondering if we should separate the article from the transcript. If so, we'd have to add the enhanced version to the episode nav as well. Note that ABC has hosted the enhanced version as a separate streaming download from the non-enhanced version. -- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯  Talk  14:56, 1 February 2008 (PST)
  • I think we should create some sort of chart to match the dialogue with the captions so people have more of an idea of what it was saying and when. -Mr.Leaf 16:53, 1 February 2008 (PST)
  • I think it would be a good idea to have a "main" article page for it, separate from the transcript. That's also a good idea to have some way of correlating the captions with the dialogue. I wonder what the best way to implement that would be? -- Graft   talk   contributions  20:20, 1 February 2008 (PST)
  • OK will separate the transcript from the article. Regarding the other issue, the easiest solution to me seem to be to interleave both transcripts: Standard dialog AND enhanced, but keep formatting somehow distinct, whether it be Tabs, Boldface, Size, Italics, <nowiki>using
    ...
    , etc., or even a small quote box for each caption. I don't think we should "footnote" the standard transcript in a way that requires the reader to go back and forth between two blocks of text. --~~~~

Merge

I think this article should be merged into the episode's main article as it doesn't need an entire page on its own. The info within it can be moved to a section of the Through the Looking Glass page, and a link to the transcript added. An enhanced version of an episode with pop-up factoids such as this does not require an entire new page, as the episode itself is in no way different, and should therefore be merged. --~~~