This person appears to be one of the most important characters in the flow of events that we've seen in the first 2 episodes of the fifth season. I think we just don't have enough information now to understand who she really is. --Mephiztofel 20:51, 25 January 2009 (UTC)
I've tried cleaning this page up, but the photo and general sections are a mess of questions and responses that I can't follow. Can anyone else follow them well enough to improve them?--Phantomrhiannon 00:44, 28 February 2009 (UTC)
SHE CANT BE PENELOPES MOTHER, IN DEAD IS DEAD BEN USES AS AN ARGUMENT THAT CHARLES HAD A DOUGHTER WITH SOMEONE FROM THE OUTSIDE, IF ELOISE IS PENNYS MOTHES AND SHE CANT BE ELLI BEACUSE SHE WAS SOMEONE FROM THE ILANS SO Theory 1b: Eloise is Penny's mother CANT BE TRUE
- First off, you need to proofread. Secondly, Eloise obviously left the Island at some point, so if she left before Widmore was banished then he could have had a child with her and she would be considered an outsider at the time.--Mrmagic522 02:42, 3 May 2009 (UTC)
We might wanna clean out the identity section on the theories page, given the reveals in The Variable.--Gibbeynator 12:19, 30 April 2009 (UTC)