FANDOM


m (Voting to Merge: Chaning vote to Keep, please refer to my comment at Locke's dreams talk)
 
Line 17: Line 17:
 
Vote '''Merge''' or '''Keep''', to determine the Fate of this page
 
Vote '''Merge''' or '''Keep''', to determine the Fate of this page
   
*'''Merge''': ''Re-adding what I posted for [[Locke's Dream]];'' While the Dreams and Visions page remains very general, with no pages and lacking sufficient details on each dream or vision, we continue to maintain short but separate articles of some character's dreams while ignoring others. I think the content on this article can fit very well in the original Dreams and Visions page, enforcing it and making it a real article to read then a page of links. I believe we have reached a good articles count for Lostpedia, that we no longer need to continue in this tedious separation of articles.---{{User:Nomad/sig}} 10:01, 5 December 2006 (PST)
+
<s>'''Merge'''</s>: ''Re-adding what I posted for [[Locke's Dream]];'' While the Dreams and Visions page remains very general, with no pages and lacking sufficient details on each dream or vision, we continue to maintain short but separate articles of some character's dreams while ignoring others. I think the content on this article can fit very well in the original Dreams and Visions page, enforcing it and making it a real article to read then a page of links. I believe we have reached a good articles count for Lostpedia, that we no longer need to continue in this tedious separation of articles.---{{User:Nomad/sig}} 10:01, 5 December 2006 (PST)
  +
*Change to '''Keep''': Please refer to my comment at [[Talk:Locke's dream#Vote to Merge|Locke's dream talk]]. I'll take the liberty of lifting off the template I added. Please feel free to re-add it again in case of further evidence.
 
*'''Don't merge''' - If we concatenate ''all'' of the dreams and visions in the show, then the article "[[Dreams and visions]] will become too long. IMHO I'd rather have separate articles. One compromise option I would endorse, however, are subpages, e.g., <nowiki>[[Dreams and visions/Eko]]</nowiki> --{{User:Santa/sig}}11:57, 5 December 2006 (PST)
 
*'''Don't merge''' - If we concatenate ''all'' of the dreams and visions in the show, then the article "[[Dreams and visions]] will become too long. IMHO I'd rather have separate articles. One compromise option I would endorse, however, are subpages, e.g., <nowiki>[[Dreams and visions/Eko]]</nowiki> --{{User:Santa/sig}}11:57, 5 December 2006 (PST)
 
'''Keep''': I think one of the reasons it was taken out to begin with was because it makes the main article too long. We do the same with the themes list and the literature list; if there's enough to expand on, it goes on a separate page, if there isn't, it just goes on the main page. --{{User:PandoraX/sig}} 07:28, 10 December 2006 (PST)
 
'''Keep''': I think one of the reasons it was taken out to begin with was because it makes the main article too long. We do the same with the themes list and the literature list; if there's enough to expand on, it goes on a separate page, if there isn't, it just goes on the main page. --{{User:PandoraX/sig}} 07:28, 10 December 2006 (PST)

Latest revision as of 14:59, December 11, 2006

Everything in this article is said in the article for "?" Edit

everything in this entry has already been said and discusses debunked theories! unless anyone can come up with a good argument otherwise, i will delete it (Mikey 17:04, 16 May 2006 (PDT))


The Cost of LivingEdit

  • These [[X's dream]] articles, by precedent, generally include both dreams and visions.
  • REQUEST: Therefore Eko's vision of Yemi and Emeka in The Cost of Living should be added to this article.

-- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯  Talk 22:10, 4 November 2006 (PST)

Renaming Edit

Yes I donn't even think this needs to be discussed, rename it now! --Blueeagleislander 23:07, 6 November 2006 (PST)

Voting to MergeEdit

Vote Merge or Keep, to determine the Fate of this page

Merge: Re-adding what I posted for Locke's Dream; While the Dreams and Visions page remains very general, with no pages and lacking sufficient details on each dream or vision, we continue to maintain short but separate articles of some character's dreams while ignoring others. I think the content on this article can fit very well in the original Dreams and Visions page, enforcing it and making it a real article to read then a page of links. I believe we have reached a good articles count for Lostpedia, that we no longer need to continue in this tedious separation of articles.--- 10:01, 5 December 2006 (PST)

  • Change to Keep: Please refer to my comment at Locke's dream talk. I'll take the liberty of lifting off the template I added. Please feel free to re-add it again in case of further evidence.
  • Don't merge - If we concatenate all of the dreams and visions in the show, then the article "Dreams and visions will become too long. IMHO I'd rather have separate articles. One compromise option I would endorse, however, are subpages, e.g., [[Dreams and visions/Eko]] -- Contrib¯ _Santa_ ¯  Talk 11:57, 5 December 2006 (PST)

Keep: I think one of the reasons it was taken out to begin with was because it makes the main article too long. We do the same with the themes list and the literature list; if there's enough to expand on, it goes on a separate page, if there isn't, it just goes on the main page. --PandoraX 07:28, 10 December 2006 (PST)

Community content is available under CC BY-NC-ND unless otherwise noted.