Title Card: If Damon & Carlton were the Man in Black & Jacob whose side would you choose?

Graham Roland: Ugh, can't decide that.

Jim Galasso: Ooh, jeez, man. That's layered, and gonna get me in trouble on so many different levels.

Melinda Hsu Taylor: Carlton I think is an expert on the water and survival, he's really good at getting, y'know, like your thirst satisfied on the Island, a lot of these images of people drinking out of banana leaves and struggling to get the water on the Black Rock, that's all Carlton.

Carlton Cuse: That is true, I probably camp much more than Damon.

Elizabeth Sarnoff: Carlton will survive, Damon will be dead in two seconds.

Melinda Hsu Taylor: He is a Star Wars fan, like I am, and so I know we'd have stuff to talk about (laughs).

Graham Roland: I'm going with the Sawyer answer, I'm on my own team.

Paul Zbyszewski: Let's put it this way, they're both the Man in Black, I mean, there's just no doubt about it.

Edward Kitsis: I'd say they're both Man In Black, and we're Jacob.

Adam Horowitz: Amen. Agreed.

Damon Lindelof: I think that I would definitely be Jacob. Y'know, because he's completely passive-aggressive, and he doesn't, he's moody, and an isolationist, and he thinks he knows better. So, these are all qualities that I demonstrate on a daily basis.

Paul Zbyszewski: I would follow either one of them, I'm not picky.

Damon Lindelof: Another reason that I am like Jacob is because I like to go around and just say "Now you're like me", which is about the most narcissistic thing someone can say to somebody.

Carlton Cuse: That is true.

Damon Lindelof: You know what, you've evolved, and the way that you've evolved is that you're like me now. Congratulations, Carlton.

Carlton Cuse: I'm gonna stay Smoke Monster.

Damon Lindelof: But you don't have to age anymore.

Carlton Cuse: I still want to be the Smoke Monster.

Damon Lindelof: Carlton, Carlton, now you're like me.

Community content is available under CC BY-NC-ND unless otherwise noted.